A Review of Emma Newman’s ‘The Vengeance’ Novel

Emma Newman’s The Vengeance, which is the first in her Vampires of Dumas series, has everything I need in a book. A female protagonist, adventure, pirates, vampires, LBTQ+ characters, mystery, a gothic chateau and werewolves-it’s almost all my favourite things rolled into one. Yet somehow this novel left me a bit flat. 

The plot is fun and intriguing, which in many ways oozes adventure and excitement. The daughter of the infamous pirate captain Anna-Marie, Morgane sails with her mother and her crew around the Caribbean on their ship the Vengeance, striking fear into the all they meet. Anna-Marie is as a fearsome pirate, who is obsessed with attacking ships belonging to the Four Chains Trading Company. However, when a raid on a Four Chains Trading Company ship goes spectacularly wrong, Morgane discovers a shocking truth about her past and sets out on a journey to her land of birth, France, to discover her heritage. 

I liked Morgane. She is feisty, blunt speaking, loyal and good person to have on your side in a fight. But despite Morgane’s tough exterior, she is in many ways extremely naïve and struggles to see the reality of things, despite the facts. She is a great heroine and in fact the book is full of great characters created by Newman. I particularly like Anna-Marie, despite only being a small part of the book and in fact I enjoyed all the female characters. They were all different, fun and complemented each other. However, other than Morgane and perhaps one other character, I felt I didn’t really get to understand them and what made them tick. Also, there were some characters whose appearance I felt was rushed and I think that is my main issue with this book.

The story is fun and is in the vein of Alexander Dumas’ swashbuckling storytelling but the storyline felt rushed, especially the ending. It could have been longer and the ending, which had me on the edge of my seat, felt particularly rushed. However, the book is the first in the series and I am hoping that future books will answer all my questions about these brilliant characters and I can carry on this swashbuckling adventure for a bit longer.

Rediscovering Treasure Island: A Timeless Adventure

To get me back into the habit of reading regularly, I went back to my favourite book as a child and the one that started my love adventure stories- Treasure Island by Robert Louis Stevenson. 

(Photo is my original copy, which is nearly 30 years old and my newer once, which was a present from my partner-can you tell, which is which?)

Robert Louis Stevenson came up with idea of pirates and buried gold, when trying to keep his stepson entertained during a wet, summers day-no DisneyPlus in 1881. It tells the story of Jim Hawkins, a boy in his early teens, who lives at the Admiral Benbow Inn with his mother and father on the South West coast of England. One day an old sailor, called Billy Bones, turns up at the Inn looking for a place to stay and the rest as they say is history. What follows is everything is everything you need in pirate story, perhaps because it is where we get most of our lore about pirates from. There is a map, buried treasure, mutiny, a tropical island, a parrot and the most famous pirate of all, Long John Silver. It is also where some of supposed ‘folklore’ regarding pirates come from, such treasure maps, walking the plank and black spots, from.

What I loved about the book and what I still love to this day, is that throughout you feel as you yourself are going on the adventure. You can feel the excitement building as Jim gets ready to leave for the island, only for the excitement to be replaced dread once people start showing their true colours. Maybe because when I first read the book it was on a particular hot day in Canada, I have always felt the obsessive heat of the island coming right off the page.  

Long John Silver is perhaps the most famous character from the book and is the inspiration for all future fictional portrayals of pirates. However, Silver in the book is a lot more than ‘Aha Jim lad’ caricature and is actually a character, who is both charming and sinister. Also, whilst many movies play on a father/son aspect of Silver and Jim’s relationship, I feel it is more ambiguous in the book. 

One thing that annoyed a child and still annoys me now, is that lack of female characters. There is only three-Jim’s mum, Silver’s wife, who is never seen and Dr Livesey’s maid (who thanks to watching endless Catherine Cookson adaptions as a child, I was convinced her and Doctor were sleeping together), who appears and disappears after one line. Jim’s mum does give a very good speech denouncing the cowardness of the men in the village but then later faints at the sight of trouble.

It is worth mentioning that when you read the book as an adult you may have a slightly different view on some of Jim’s actions. As a child doing rash, impulsive things can make perfect sense in to you. But reading them as I an adult, I did spend a lot of time thinking of ‘what the Hell are you doing’ and imagining Dr Livesey and the Squire muttering ‘for f***sake’ under their breath throughout the book. This that in mind, I can see what author, John Drake was going when he made Jim the rival in his retelling The Traitor of Treasure Island but that’s a review for another day. But I don’t think Jim is the villain, it’s more that I am kind of despairing of him! However, if you have not yet read this novel, do not despair of him too much and enjoy this classic adventure tale.